The Hidden Email Mistake Tanking Your Show-Up Rates

Listen to this episode on Apple or Spotify.

---

You’ve mapped out your live workshop, crafted your slides, and poured hours into planning your webinar or summit. You’re ready for the big day.

But then… the dreaded low show-up rate.

Most people assume the problem is one of two things:

• Their topic didn’t land.
• Their emails weren’t written well enough.

But the truth? Inbox confusion is the real culprit.

The Real Culprit Behind Low Show-Up Rates

When subscribers feel like random strangers in your list instead of VIP guests, trust drops—and so does attendance.

Here’s what inbox confusion looks like:

• Your subscribers register for your event… and then keep getting promo emails begging them to register again.
• They’re left wondering, “Didn’t I already sign up?”
• Instead of feeling hyped for it, they feel second-guessed.

And once that trust cracks, you’re not just hurting attendance. You’re hurting the relationship long-term.

A Story From My Inbox (a.k.a. What Not to Do)

I recently signed up for a virtual summit. I was excited, brand new to this person’s world, and ready to learn.

But the next few days? My inbox turned into Groundhog Day.

• “Have you grabbed your free ticket yet?”
• “There’s still time to claim your spot!”

Over and over, even though I was already registered.

My systems brain knew right away: they hadn’t set up proper segmentation. My customer-experience brain thought: what a missed opportunity. Instead of nurturing me, they wasted three emails asking me to do something I’d already done.

The Systems Script

So how do you prevent inbox confusion and actually build momentum toward your event?

That’s where a simple systems prescription comes in.

Symptom:

Your subscribers keep getting emails asking them to register for your event—even after they’ve already signed up. They feel confused, start to wonder if they did something wrong, and eventually stop paying attention.

Diagnosis:

The problem isn’t your live event—it’s segmentation. Without tags, groups, or exclusions, everyone gets treated the same. That means your “already registered” crowd gets lumped in with your “still deciding” crowd, creating a messy, trust-eroding experience.

The Script:

Segment your list like a music festival wristband. Tag new registrants at the door (“Event Registered”), exclude them from promo sequences, and repurpose your promo emails as nurture reminders by swapping the CTA from “Register Now” to “Can’t wait to see you live.”

This tiny backend tweak makes attendees feel seen—and when people feel seen, they show up.

Why These Systems Matter

When someone registers for your event, they’ve already said yes. From that point on, every touchpoint should feel like confirmation that they made the right choice.

But if they keep getting promo emails asking them to register again, that yes starts to feel invisible. Instead of feeling like a valued guest, they feel like a number in your list.

That’s the difference segmentation makes. It’s not about being fancy with tech—it’s about creating a smoother, more human experience:

• Attendees know exactly what’s next.
• Your emails reinforce excitement instead of creating doubt.
• Show-up rates rise because people feel personally invited, not spammed.

The best part? Once these systems are in place, they run quietly in the background—freeing you up to focus on hosting the event, not babysitting the backend.

Ready to Fix Your Own Inbox Confusion?

This is exactly the kind of invisible crack we repair inside The Systems Pharmacy.

Every week, members send me a short video of their backend—whether it’s funnels, automations, or event campaigns—and I send back a personalized strategy + tech walkthrough within 48 hours.

Together, we clean up those invisible gaps so your business feels clear, reliable, and welcoming—for you and your audience.

Check out The Systems Pharmacy here.